Caverna: The Cave Farmers

IMG_1378

Just realized I haven’t blogged about “Caverna: The Cave Farmers” yet, the  heaviest board game I’ve bought so far, literally. By Amazon it weights 7.8 pounds. It took me more than 20 minutes just to punch out all the tokens.

Caverna is basically an “Agricola 2.0”. If you’ve played Agricola before, you can easily find lots of similarities in Caverna. Fixed number of rounds, sowing vegetables and harvesting crops, feeding animals and turning your farm to a zoo, and of course, feeding your family and struggling on the line of starving. Hence, it’s pretty easy for Agricola players to learn Caverna despite the length of the rule book.

But after a few plays I noticed there were some obvious differences between Caverna and Agricola, which actually made a veteran Agricola player like me feel weird. It was not until almost 10 games that I started getting the hang of it.

The first impression of Caverna was everything goes faster, twice faster. In Agricola the game gets more and more going on later in the game, the Caverna the “game accelerating trajectory” is even more dramatic. For example, Slash and Burn (build a field and sow) is an end-game “power move” in Agricola, but in Caverna it’s available from the beginning. In Caverna, a high-level dwarf doing a 4-loot expedition feels like he can single-handedly turn the farm over in one day, which gives you an exciting feeling that is rarely found in Agricola. On this point, I like Caverna better.

Another great part of Caverna is it increased the strategy diversity. In Agricola almost every game and everyone aims for the same main route: building rooms and adding family members. The strategy variety in Agricola greatly depends on the career/development cards. In Caverna because of the introduction of Expedition and the general increase of action capabilities, the value of an action can be much more dramatically different, so a smaller family size is not necessarily a huge disadvantage, in some cases it could even be an advantage (your higher-level dwarf can act earlier). Scoring changes for family members also reduced the importance of having more family members. Considering a few other scoring and rule changes, I feel Caverna really enables more feasible strategies in the base framework of the game, instead of relying on a huge set of random cards.

Using a fixed set of Furnishing Tiles to replace career/development cards is a bold design. Agricola’s great replayability mainly comes from the random cards, which is a double-edge sword. A strong hand or just one or two combos can sometimes give a player unfair advantages in a game; and new players usually cannot figure out their cards well that either slow down the game or make their winning chance very dim. Therefore I definitely welcome a try for a more transparent and balanced mechanism to provide similar replayability. So far I have mixed feelings about Caverna’s Furnishing Tiles. They’re public information so when a new player is confused you can easily explain. However they don’t seem to be very well balanced as far as I can see. There are obviously strong tiles and almost useless ones. Maybe I haven’t experimented enough strategies to see more usefulness from some cards. Anyway it’s still better to have all Furnishing Tiles in a public market so any player can buy, so the imbalance introduced by drawing is eliminated.

Overall I recommend this game to people who like Agricola and would like to experience something similar and new. Have the expectation that you might be confused for a few games and won’t immediately enjoy it even if you know Agricola well. It’s a real v2.0, not a v1.1.

冰火版图版和农场主

十一去渣古家和渣古索头夫妇玩了半天桌游。除了蟑螂这个总是很出色的开胃游戏之外,则是开了冰火版图和农场主这两个我都是第一次玩的游戏。

冰火版图版果然是个很嘴炮的游戏。虽说最多只有十回合,但是实际耗时是相当的长,我们玩了五个回合就鸣金收兵了。游戏的规则还比较简单明了,总体来说比较像战棋,但更重要的还是玩家之间的合纵连横,也就是嘴炮……因为里面的战棋成分并不复杂,推演形势并且在外交上做出有效的决定才能生存下去。摆开一副地图加上贴近原著的设定,对于读过这部小说的人来说还是挺有意思的。另外这游戏还是相当血腥的,只要想象一下战棋游戏里面肆意虐杀的电脑换成真人玩家,这个还是比较可怕的。正常游戏一共有十回合,如果五人游戏的话恐怕六七回合就会有人出局,downtime也是相当的长啊。总的来说算是个fans向而且相当hardcore的游戏,虽然规则不算难。

农场主(Agricola)是非常非常赫赫有名的桌游,因为它在BGG上曾经长期占据第一名的位置,只是最近才被波多黎各超过。这个游戏有300多个token,刚上手的时候感觉有巨多的要素,又要养人又要种菜又要养牲口又要盖房子什么的,但是流程相当的流畅,跟着流程玩几回合很快就能上手,从这一点就可以看出这是个好游戏了。这游戏的农家乐背景使得它广受女玩家喜爱,xw就表示盖个房种个菜养头猪什么的很好玩。作为一个最后以计算VP决定胜负的游戏,它的基本策略也不外乎“前期谋发展,后期谋分数”这样的方向,所以有经验的玩家还是很快就能进入状态。我们这盘最后以渣古lp vikkie 44分获胜告终,我有好几块空地罚了几分,不过发展卡的分比较多,以41分排在第二。第一次玩就有这个分数我觉得还不错了,哈哈。